Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn schools. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng
Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn schools. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng

Chủ Nhật, 19 tháng 2, 2012

The Tebow laws: Should homeschooled kids play sports for public schools?

Virginia is on the verge of passing a law affecting youngsters who dream of following the career path of homeschooled-kid-turned-NFL star Tim Tebow Virginia is close to amending its laws so homeschooled kids can participate in extracurricular activities at public schools — namely, sports. At least 25 states already have some kind of "Tebow law," so named because Denver Broncos quarterback Tim Tebow was homeschooled in Florida but played on a public school football team. The number of homeschooled kids in the U.S. is growing, say advocates: From 1.5 million in 2007 to 2 million now. Are Tebow laws a good idea?

No. Public school isn't "a la carte": If you're a parent who doesn't "think the school's math or English program is good enough for your child, but playing on that school's football team is," you're like a kid who wants dessert without dinner, says Zack Plair in the Paragould, Ark., Daily Press. Tebow law advocates say it's about fairness — we pay school taxes, let our kids play — but such "a la carte" public-schooling is unfair to students who participate in the system. I pay taxes for the whole road, but I can't "drive on the left side of the highway" or "pass on the shoulder." There is "a system in place, and the integrity of that system depends on everyone using it a certain way."
"So-called 'Tebow laws' create slippery slope"

What's wrong with treating schools like a buffet? "What's so terrible about one more choice for kids and their families?" asks Lucy Steigerwald at Reason. In fact, why stop with homeschooled kids? We should open public school sports teams to private school students, too. If public schools want taxpayer funding, parents deserve as many choices as possible, and that includes letting in "a thousand homeschooled Christian dorks so that they too can be future football stars."
"'Tebow law'... already lets columnists complain about too much choice"

Homeschoolers should "meet the public schools halfway": Sports bring people together, and "integrating homeschoolers into our public education system advances the goal of commonality," says Andrew Rotherham at TIME. But if they want to integrate, homeschoolers need to play by public school rules, especially regarding academic eligibility. Linking sports to grades is "a hard-won education reform," and for homeschoolers, academic eligibility means accepting "some sensible regulation of homeschooling quality."
"Should homeschoolers be allowed on public-school sports teams?"

View this article on TheWeek.com Get 4 Free Issues of The Week

Other stories from this topic:

Like on Facebook - Follow on Twitter - Sign-up for Daily Newsletter

View the original article here

Thứ Năm, 9 tháng 2, 2012

An L.A. school's sex-abuse scandal: The extreme fallout

The entire staff at a low-income, heavily Latino grade school is replaced so investigators can dig into deeply unsettling accusations

It all started when students at Los Angeles' Miramonte Elementary School and their parents learned last week that a longtime third-grade teacher, Mark Berndt, had been arrested for allegedly committing lewd acts on 23 kids in his classroom. A few days later, a second-grade teacher at the same school, Martin Springer, was arrested on charges of groping a 7-year-old girl. Then, late Monday, Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent John Deasy yanked every single one of the school's 128 teachers, janitors, administrators, and cafeteria workers, placed them in another school, and brought in an entirely new staff at Miramonte — all so investigators could find out who knew what, and when. Here, a look at this "sordid" scandal:

What exactly are the teachers accused of?
The charges "are both horrible and weird, in the least pleasant sense of that word," says KJ Dell'Antonia in The New York Times. Berndt, 61, allegedly played bizarre "tasting games" with some students in his classroom, where he would blindfold them, put cockroaches on their face, and feed them his semen on a spoon or cookie — then photograph the lewd ritual. He was actually removed from school a year ago, after a film-processor turned some of the disturbing photos over to the police. Springer, 49, was charged with inappropriately touching a 7-year-old girl in his classroom.

SEE MORE: The deadly, 'inexplicable' grenade attack in Belgium

How long did this go on?
That's a big focus of the school district's investigation. Berndt had been at the low-income, heavily Latino grade school for 32 years, and the Los Angeles Times says students and parents have come forward in recent days with complaints reaching back as far as 20 years. In announcing his "clean sweep" of Miramonte, Superintendent Deasy said investigators will dig to see if there was a "culture of silence" at the school. 

Is there any connection between Berndt and Springer?
Investigators say they know of no connection. But Brian Claypool, a lawyer for some alleged victims, tells the New York Daily News that his clients say Berndt and Springer were "best buds." Claypool also alleges that a third teacher, a female in a neighboring classroom, was involved in the abuse, handpicking pretty girls from her class for Berndt's sick games. "The conspiracy theories have to be going nuts in that community," says Jeanne Sager at The Stir. "And I don't blame those parents one bit."

SEE MORE: Haley Barbour's 'shocking' pardon spree: A guide

Is replacing the entire school's staff really necessary?
"We intend to interview every adult," from principal to playground helper, Superintendent Deasy told parents. "I mean every single solitary adult who works at Miramonte." But many students, and lots of their parents, say it's disruptive and unfair to yank all the teachers, since most or even all of them had no part in this scandal. I disagree, says Monica Bielanko at Babble. "Replacing the staff shows dedication to making it right and doing everything within their power to not let it happen again." Count me unimpressed, says The Times' Dell'Antonia. "The message I hear is, 'We don’t know how to know whom to trust.'" That doesn't inspire a lot of confidence.

Will the abused children be alright?
Let's hope so. Along with well-vetted replacement teachers, a psychiatric social worker is being placed in each Miramonte classroom. "There has to be someone in their life who can re-create a trusting relationship with the child to undo the idea that they can't trust anybody," says Ginger Clark at the University of Southern California.  Sadly, "I don't think they'll ever get over it," says UCLA's Paul Abramson. Predatory teachers do a lot of damage, and "you see people who are 50 and are still traumatized about events that happened to them when they were 10."

SEE MORE: The NYPD'S infrared gun scanner

Sources: AP, Babble, Los Angeles Times (2), New York Daily News, New York Times, The Stir, TIME, Washington Post

View this article on TheWeek.com Get 4 Free Issues of The Week

Other stories from this topic:

Like on Facebook - Follow on Twitter - Sign-up for Daily Newsletter

View the original article here